Alright, let’s talk about these so-called yoga mat flip flops. My journey with them started pretty simply. My old plastic flip flops were just killing my feet, you know? Like walking on hard rocks after a while. I wanted something softer, something I could actually walk around in all day without feeling beat up.

So I started poking around. Saw these things advertised as “yoga mat” flip flops. Sounded comfy, right? Like walking on a cloud, or at least, on my yoga mat, which is pretty nice. I figured, why not give them a shot? What’s the worst that could happen?
My First Attempt
I grabbed the first pair I saw that looked decent and weren’t crazy expensive. Got them home, put them on. Okay, yeah, definitely squishier than the old plastic ones. That part was nice. But after wearing them for a few days, I noticed some stuff.
- They got indented really fast where my heel and toes sat. Like, permanent dents.
- The squishiness was almost too much? Felt a bit unstable sometimes.
- The straps were this fabric stuff that looked nice but started rubbing weirdly after they got wet once.
They weren’t awful, but they weren’t the miracle I was hoping for. They felt kinda cheap, honestly, even though they weren’t the absolute cheapest. Wore them out pretty quickly too.
Round Two: Getting Pickier
I wasn’t ready to give up yet. The idea of that soft footbed was still appealing. So I decided to look a bit closer this time. I realized not all “yoga mat” materials are the same. Some felt denser, some felt spongier. The straps were different too – some thicker, some thinner, some different materials.
This time I went for a pair that felt a little firmer when I squeezed the sole in the store. Not hard, but like it had more substance, more bounce-back. The straps were also a simpler, smoother material. They cost a bit more, but I figured maybe you get what you pay for sometimes.
Finding My Footwear Groove
Bingo. These were different. They still had that comfortable give, that softness you expect from the name, but it was supportive. My feet didn’t just sink in and stay there. It felt like walking on a very firm, high-quality mat, not a cheap squishy one.

Here’s what I liked about this second pair:
- Better rebound: The sole squishes but bounces back, feels more supportive.
- Durability: They didn’t get those permanent deep dents nearly as fast. Still look pretty good after a lot of use.
- Strap comfort: The simpler straps didn’t rub or chafe, even when I wore them for hours.
- Good balance: Not too soft, not too hard. Just right for walking around, doing errands, chilling at home.
So, yeah. “Best” is tricky. What I found is that the idea of yoga mat flip flops is great, but the execution varies a lot. The super squishy ones weren’t for me. I needed something with that cushion but also some actual support. Took trying a couple of pairs to figure out what my feet actually liked. It wasn’t really about yoga at all, just finding comfy material that lasts.